The family requested I share their experience. Identifying details have been changed to protect privacy.
Some children don’t just prefer to be in charge. They seem to need it. When every routine becomes a negotiation and every change feels like a crisis, parents may wonder whether they’re dealing with defiance, anxiety, or a child who simply doesn’t know how to feel safe without control.
I once worked with a young girl between the ages of 6 and 9 who needed to be in charge of nearly everything. Her family lived in Brandon, FL, and made the drive to my play therapy office in Tampa because ordinary family life had become one long negotiation. Like many parents searching for a child therapist, they weren’t looking for someone to give their daughter a label. They wanted to understand why getting dressed, leaving the house, completing homework, and going to bed had all become power struggles.
Even the drive to see me could become part of the problem. She wanted to choose the route, the music, where her sibling sat, and what snack they brought in the car. If her parent missed a turn or changed the plan, she could become so upset that the entire family arrived at the appointment exhausted.
At home, she decided which games everyone played, where people sat, what her younger sibling could touch, and how family routines were supposed to happen. Her parents had tried consequences, rewards, explanations, and warnings before transitions. Sometimes those strategies helped, but they still felt as though every boundary invited another argument.
They worried that she was becoming entitled or manipulative. I understood why. When a child tries to control the entire household, it can be difficult to see anything beneath the behavior except defiance.
Was There a Reason She Needed Control?
Sometimes children want to be in charge because they’re growing more independent and testing what they can do for themselves. Some children are also naturally more intense, cautious, or slow to adjust. They may need more time than other children to accept a new routine, a different plan, or an unexpected change.
That doesn’t automatically mean a child has experienced trauma, has an anxiety disorder, or has a deeper behavioral problem. A strong personality and a growing need for independence can be part of normal childhood development. It becomes more concerning when the need for control is rigid, appears throughout the child’s daily life, causes frequent emotional meltdowns, or keeps the family from participating in ordinary activities.
For this little girl, there wasn’t one dramatic event that explained everything. She had always disliked surprises and transitions, but the previous year had included a new school, changes in a parent’s work schedule, and several shifts in who picked her up and where she spent her afternoons. None of those changes were harmful on their own, but together they made her life feel less predictable.
Control had become her way of managing that uncertainty. If she chose every detail, she didn’t have to wonder what would happen next. If everyone followed her rules, she didn’t have to feel the discomfort of adjusting to someone else’s plan.
Her behavior wasn’t proof that her parents had failed or that something terrible had happened to her. It was a coping strategy. Unfortunately, it was also a coping strategy that left the entire family frustrated and taught her that uncomfortable feelings had to be avoided rather than managed.
What Her Sandtray Revealed
I used child-centered play therapy to give her a way to express herself without expecting her to sit across from me and explain her behavior like a tiny adult. In child-centered play therapy, I follow the child’s lead while maintaining clear and consistent therapeutic limits. The child is given space to explore feelings, relationships, conflicts, and experiences through play at a pace that feels manageable.
She was especially drawn to sandtray therapy. A sandtray allows a child to choose miniature people, animals, buildings, vehicles, fences, and other objects to create a small world in the sand. I don’t tell a child what the scene means or treat every plastic dinosaur like it holds the secrets of the universe. I pay attention to repeated themes, reflect what I notice, and allow the child’s story to develop without forcing it.
Recent Posts
Her sandtray worlds were carefully controlled. She built roads that could only be used in one direction, surrounded houses with fences, and placed one girl in the center who decided where every other figure was allowed to go. If a miniature fell over or left a mark in the wrong part of the sand, she stopped to repair the entire area before continuing.
Over several sessions, the same themes returned. Families were moved unexpectedly. Roads were blocked. Characters weren’t told where they were going until they arrived. The girl in charge prevented anything surprising from happening, but she also prevented anyone from moving freely.
I didn’t tell her that her sandtray represented anxiety or announce that I had uncovered the meaning of her behavior. Children don’t need adults barging into their play and explaining their own feelings to them. Instead, I reflected the experiences she created:
“She needs to know the plan.” “It feels safer when she decides.”
Alongside the play therapy sessions, I helped her parents respond differently at home. Through parent coaching, we focused on offering appropriate choices without handing over adult responsibility. She could choose between two outfits, but she couldn’t decide whether she went to school. She could choose the bedtime story, but she couldn’t move bedtime until she felt ready.
Her parents also became more predictable about the decisions they made. They gave her warnings before transitions, followed through on plans when possible, and acknowledged her disappointment without reopening every decision for debate. The goal wasn’t to prevent her from ever feeling upset. It was to help her build emotional regulation skills so she could experience disappointment without needing the entire family to rearrange itself around her.
Learning That a Change Wasn’t a Disaster
Her progress was gradual. In the sandtray, she began leaving openings in the fences. Characters were allowed to travel along more than one road, and other figures occasionally made decisions without receiving permission from the girl in the center. When something fell over, she no longer needed to rebuild the entire scene.
The changes at home were just as ordinary, which is often how meaningful progress looks. She still preferred knowing the plan, but a change no longer ruined the entire day. She recovered from disappointment more quickly, allowed her sibling to choose some activities, and began asking questions instead of immediately issuing demands.
Several months into therapy, the family took a trip from Brandon to Ford’s Garage in Westchase for burgers. Their daughter had already decided where everyone would sit and what the afternoon would look like. When they arrived, the restaurant was busy and the booth she wanted wasn’t available.
Her parents could see her becoming tense. In the past, they might have bargained, waited indefinitely for the correct table, or abandoned the outing before the meltdown reached full strength. This time, they acknowledged that she was disappointed and calmly offered two available seating choices.
She crossed her arms. She complained. She took a few minutes to decide.
Then she chose a table and ate her burger.
It wasn’t a dramatic breakthrough accompanied by inspirational music. It was a child experiencing an unwanted change, feeling upset, and discovering that she could still be okay. For her family, that small moment represented months of work.
A child who needs to control everything isn’t always hiding a major trauma, and the behavior doesn’t automatically mean something is wrong with them. Sometimes the child is testing independence. Sometimes their temperament makes change more difficult. Sometimes anxiety, stress, or an unpredictable season of life makes control feel safer.
Understanding the reason doesn’t mean allowing the behavior to run the household. Children can need empathy and firm boundaries at the same time. They can be disappointed without being rescued from every disappointment.
The goal wasn’t to teach this little girl that she’d never be in charge.
It was to help her understand that she didn’t have to be in charge of everything to feel safe.
